It's taken me a few days to get back and reply to all the comments and advice I received after my last post. There were numerous blog comments, Facebook comments and messages, and phone calls from many of you.
May I just say, I so appreciate everything that was said. Especially the stories many of you shared about your own experiences, whether in the past or present. It's especially wonderful and relieving to know that several of you don't have advice but you feel for me because you're going through it too. I already knew that to some degree but it was good to be reminded. As one of my dear friends said, "your kid sounds totally normal, and you sound like a normal frustrated mom." The blog world has "Wordless Wednesday"......why don't we start up a "Terrible Twosday" as sort of an AA group? Sometimes it's just nice to know you're not the only one.
Rather than replying individually to all the comments and messages I received I'm just going to let my mind race here. I received advice that others going through the same phase with their kids might like to know. I won't mention names, but those of you who left your thoughts should recognize my replies to your advice.
As I received your comments, it was obvious that many of you are anti-spanking. I need to clarify that I'm not necessarily pro-spanking. I spank my son but it's not a frequent thing and heaven knows I don't enjoy it. We've tried other discipline alternatives such as time out or taking privileges away. Time out didn't seem to affect him much and taking privileges away only led to major tantrums (throwing things, breaking things, hitting us, etc.) which only led to more discipline which only led to greater tantrums and on and on and on. Once his mind is set on something there's no changing it. Also, the only thing(s) he's really attached to enough to affect him are his blankies and he wouldn't sleep if I took them away so they're not an option. Giving him a quick (non-abusive) spank gets his attention, shows him we disapprove of his action, and it's over. Rather than escalating, the moment is terminated. I'm not justifying my choice to spank him, I'm just shedding a little light on why it works better (for my son) than other alternatives.
May I just say, I so appreciate everything that was said. Especially the stories many of you shared about your own experiences, whether in the past or present. It's especially wonderful and relieving to know that several of you don't have advice but you feel for me because you're going through it too. I already knew that to some degree but it was good to be reminded. As one of my dear friends said, "your kid sounds totally normal, and you sound like a normal frustrated mom." The blog world has "Wordless Wednesday"......why don't we start up a "Terrible Twosday" as sort of an AA group? Sometimes it's just nice to know you're not the only one.
Rather than replying individually to all the comments and messages I received I'm just going to let my mind race here. I received advice that others going through the same phase with their kids might like to know. I won't mention names, but those of you who left your thoughts should recognize my replies to your advice.
As I received your comments, it was obvious that many of you are anti-spanking. I need to clarify that I'm not necessarily pro-spanking. I spank my son but it's not a frequent thing and heaven knows I don't enjoy it. We've tried other discipline alternatives such as time out or taking privileges away. Time out didn't seem to affect him much and taking privileges away only led to major tantrums (throwing things, breaking things, hitting us, etc.) which only led to more discipline which only led to greater tantrums and on and on and on. Once his mind is set on something there's no changing it. Also, the only thing(s) he's really attached to enough to affect him are his blankies and he wouldn't sleep if I took them away so they're not an option. Giving him a quick (non-abusive) spank gets his attention, shows him we disapprove of his action, and it's over. Rather than escalating, the moment is terminated. I'm not justifying my choice to spank him, I'm just shedding a little light on why it works better (for my son) than other alternatives.
I will say, it's been a while since we tried time out. Maybe it's worth trying again now that he's a little older. I think he's getting to the point that we'll be able to sit him down and really discuss what he's done and why it's inappropriate. Up to this point, as much as we try to reason with him he just doesn't listen, nor does he really understand. That doesn't keep us from discussing with him- -we do our best to make sure he knows why he shouldn't have done something- -but he just isn't to a point that sole communication deters him from doing something he shouldn't do.
Have I heard of the book "Parenting With Love and Logic?" I have! In fact, I have the book and I pulled it out the day before my post =0) I was trained numerous times in Love and Logic when I worked for the After School Club for Logan City and I agree, it is a very effective tool. It's been a few years so it will be good for me to go through the book again, especially now Teryn has hit this stage. In general though, the concept of allowing/creating choices for Teryn and empowering him to make them is very important to us.
Monitoring his diet. Teryn has been a lightweight since day one. He doesn't eat much. In fact, it's amazing the amount of energy he has with such little caloric intake! With that said, I try to make sure that the calories he takes in are of value. I'm not the best at always providing perfectly balanced meals, but I do make sure he isn't eating sweets if he hasn't eaten good food. If he's eaten a good meal, I might give him some fruit snacks, one cookie, a Dum Dum sucker, or something small like that. Otherwise, I'd say he has a pretty good, healthy diet. I don't feel that his outbursts are a result of what he eats/doesn't eat.
Since my last post, I've put child-proof handles on Teryn's door, the laundry room (back porch) door, and the bathroom door. Eliminating the options has helped tremendously. In my heart of hearts knew it would, I was just being optimistic hoping that he could figure it out and simply learn what he shouldn't do. I think I was expecting too much from such a little guy.
Tight schedule. I agree, it's the only way. After discussing with one of my wise nanny friends, I probably need to be more strict about a nap. Now that I've put a child-proof handle on his bedroom door and I don't have to worry about him getting out I just need to put him down at the same time everyday and let him do the rest. Another friend mentioned that there are days when she puts her little girl down and she chooses to play rather than sleep, but the fact she had the chance to nap is what's important. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink. That's a good mommy-law to live by.
I mentioned I like the idea of some sort of sticker chart to reward Teryn when he's obedient. A friend offered the idea of a punch card. Whenever Teryn is obedient or does something good he gets a punch (or several punches) and if he's naughty he loses a punch. I love this idea, but I'd add my own twist to it. I don't think Teryn would understand simply losing a punch if he's naughty. He would need to have a punch taken away to really get it and be motivated to keep it from happening again. I am still imagining more of a sticker chart (just because he loves stickers) with the ability to remove stickers when he's naughty. I think that would help him catch on a little quicker.
Another friend noticed the nature of the things Teryn gets into. The texture of detergent, the shiny surface of the DVDs, etc. She offered the idea that in theory, children seek sensory input they need. This could very well be the case with Teryn. I need to be sure and offer opportunities for him to fulfill those sensory needs in more productive, acceptable ways.
I think that basically touches on every bit of advice I was offered. Again, thank you all for your ideas and personal experiences. You helped me step back and see what's going on from different perspectives and it's already helped so much.
I've had a few other thoughts come to mind as I've considered what we're dealing with. I think when it really comes down to it, Teryn does the things he does just because he can! He's finally figured out how to open doors, so of course he's not going to let a door stand in his way. He's also figured out that he can climb to get anything he wants, so of course he's going to prove his ability. I can definitely imagine that's a factor in why he's doing what he's doing. Also, he may not be affected by the amount of attention Ryder gets, but I think he notices the nature of the attention he gets. Ryder never gets in trouble so it's probably upsetting to Teryn that he does. Let the "you're older, you should know better" days begin, I suppose. I need to make sure I give Teryn extra love and attention, especially while Ryder is sleeping and we can be one-on-one. Additionally, he needs to spend as much time outside as possible. He's been cooped up inside with me and I think it makes him crazy. He is so much happier when he gets out. This morning we went for a walk. We stopped to pet the neighbor's cows (one really let me pet her! She tried to lick me too! I must smell good). A semi came down the road and I tried to teach Teryn how to pump his fist for the driver to honk his horn. He honked and about scared Teryn to death! I laughed the rest of the way home, ha ha! Teryn laughed too but he held his chest like his heart was about to beat out of it. Poor kid. When we got home I put Ryder down to sleep and Teryn and I went back out to the yard to play baseball. All the time we spent outside really helped him to be happy and more obedient throughout the day. He even took a 2 hour nap! Thank heaven the weather is warming up so we can get out more often.
Tyson reminded me the other day that we asked for what we're going through. He's right. When Teryn was born we both hoped he would grow to have a strong mind. We both wanted him to be active, adventurous, and driven. Well here we are, getting just what we wanted! I know I'll be grateful, I just need to get through this. Another friend told me to keep good notes and write a book. By the time we're through, that may not be a bad idea =0)
I think that basically touches on every bit of advice I was offered. Again, thank you all for your ideas and personal experiences. You helped me step back and see what's going on from different perspectives and it's already helped so much.
I've had a few other thoughts come to mind as I've considered what we're dealing with. I think when it really comes down to it, Teryn does the things he does just because he can! He's finally figured out how to open doors, so of course he's not going to let a door stand in his way. He's also figured out that he can climb to get anything he wants, so of course he's going to prove his ability. I can definitely imagine that's a factor in why he's doing what he's doing. Also, he may not be affected by the amount of attention Ryder gets, but I think he notices the nature of the attention he gets. Ryder never gets in trouble so it's probably upsetting to Teryn that he does. Let the "you're older, you should know better" days begin, I suppose. I need to make sure I give Teryn extra love and attention, especially while Ryder is sleeping and we can be one-on-one. Additionally, he needs to spend as much time outside as possible. He's been cooped up inside with me and I think it makes him crazy. He is so much happier when he gets out. This morning we went for a walk. We stopped to pet the neighbor's cows (one really let me pet her! She tried to lick me too! I must smell good). A semi came down the road and I tried to teach Teryn how to pump his fist for the driver to honk his horn. He honked and about scared Teryn to death! I laughed the rest of the way home, ha ha! Teryn laughed too but he held his chest like his heart was about to beat out of it. Poor kid. When we got home I put Ryder down to sleep and Teryn and I went back out to the yard to play baseball. All the time we spent outside really helped him to be happy and more obedient throughout the day. He even took a 2 hour nap! Thank heaven the weather is warming up so we can get out more often.
Tyson reminded me the other day that we asked for what we're going through. He's right. When Teryn was born we both hoped he would grow to have a strong mind. We both wanted him to be active, adventurous, and driven. Well here we are, getting just what we wanted! I know I'll be grateful, I just need to get through this. Another friend told me to keep good notes and write a book. By the time we're through, that may not be a bad idea =0)
Just read this article the other day and it's been helpful to look at things a little differently. I, too, enjoy the Love and Logic book!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.ahaparenting.com/parenting-tools/positive-discipline/use-positive-discipline
I love knowing I'm not the only frustrated parent, too. I say we start the AA parenting club, but with a cooler name. lol.
You're doing a great job being a mom, Dani! The fact that you took the time to seek help/insight says a lot about your ability to parent by itself! You're awesome!
Just thought I'd tell you that I think you're a great mother. And that I think more kids would be better behaved (as children AND adults) if they got swatted every once in a while. Seriously.
ReplyDelete(Does that mean I'm pro-spanking?)
I just read this and although it seems like you have come to terms with everything I'm going to tell you that I am STILL going through this with Ethan. He is four. Nice. I loved all the advice everyone gave you and I'll add my two bits. When Ethan gets out of bed at night, we have found that making bedtime more appealing than being out of bed works the best. I have a chore jar and if he gets out of bed I tell him to pick a chore and he has to do it...things like organize the books, toys, dust the piano, wash a window, wipe baseboards, simple things.... After one chore he always gets back in bed because at least there he can play quietly. More fun. Better choice. This works for Ethan and he is a bit older. Hopefully everything gets resolved and you aren't dealing with the bedtime thing at age 4!! But everything gets easier when kids have the ability to reason with you. Teryn isn't there yet but he will be.
ReplyDelete